Account books of the Moscow Print Yard (1622-1700): the origins of cost accounting in Russia

Marina I. Sidorova, Dmitry V. Nazarov

Resumen


This paper reports the results from the study of the account books (1622-1700) of the Moscow Print Yard, the largest Russian state manufactory in the 17th century. This case confirms the existence of sophisticated calculative techniques in pre-industrial societies and adds an argument in the debate about origins of the cost accounting. Management of the Russian state owned monopoly enterprise used the original cost technique not for efficiency reasons but only for pricing and control of material, labour and financial resources.

We also investigate the influence of the organizational changes at the Moscow Print Yard on the evolution of its bookkeeping practice for eighty years. The cause of calculative practice development was intuitive reaction of enterprise management to changing political and economic circumstances. The methods of product costing, pricing, expense recognition and production control are examined within the political, economic, and social context of Russia at the time. The 17th century was the epoch of the formation of the Russian state and the awareness of the state power as the driver for governing of a public life. The paper argues that the political attitudes of the state determined the organizational changes at the state manufactory and transformation of traditional bookkeeping practice to the new type of administrative activity – cost accounting.

Palabras clave


Cost accounting, 17th century, Moscow Print Yard, state enterprise, organizational changes

Texto completo:

PDF

Referencias


Russian State Archive of Ancient Documents (RGADA). Moscow. Fond 1182, Inventory 1, Documents 1, 2, 5-9, 11, 17, 19, 20, 22-24, 27-28, 32-34, 37, 38, 40, 48, 61, 67, 69, 70, 75, 78, 81, 90; Fond 1182, Inventory 3, Documents 27-32, 51, 111. Российский государственный архив древних актов. Москва.

Baños J, Gutiérrez F, Álvarez‐Dardet Espejo C and Carrasco Fenech F (2005) Govern(mentality) and accounting: The influence of different Enlightenment discourses in two Spanish cases (1761-1777). Abacus 41(2): 181-210.

Baños J and Gutiérrez-Hidalgo F (2011) Publishing patterns of accounting history research in generalist journals: Lessons from the past. Accounting history 16(3): 331-342.

Belokurov S (1887) Moscow Print yard in 1649. Chteniya Obshchestva istorii i drevnostey Rossii 4, part 4:1-32. Белокуров С.А. Московский печатный двор в 1649г. Чтения Общества истории и древностей России.

Boyns T and Edwards J (2013) A History of Management Accounting: the British Experience. New York: Routledge.

Burley K (1958) Some accounting records of an eighteen-century clothier. Accounting Research 9(1): 50-60.

Carmona S (2006) The History of Management Accounting in France, Italy, Portugal, and Spain. Handbooks of Management Accounting Research 2: 905-922.

Carmona E and Gómez D (2002) Early Cost Management Practices, State Ownership and Market Competition: The Case of the Royal Textile Mill of Guadalajara, 1717- 44. Accounting, Business and Financial History 12(2): 231-251.

Carmona S and Donoso R (2004) Cost Accounting in Early Regulated Markets: The Case of the Royal Soap Factory of Seville (1525-1692). Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 23: 129-157.

Carmona S, Ezzamel M and Gutiérrez F (1997) Control and Cost Accounting Practices in the Spanish Royal Tobacco Factory. Accounting, Organizations and Society 22(5): 411-446.

Carvalho JM, Rodrigues LL and Craig R (2007) Early cost accounting practices and private ownership: the silk factory company of Portugal. Accounting Historians Journal 34: 57-89.

Edwards J (1989) Industrial cost accounting developments in Britain to 1830: a review article. Accounting and Business research 19(3): 305-317.

Edwards J and Boyns T (1992) Industrial organization and accounting innovation: charcoal ironmaking in England 1690-1783. Management Accounting Research 3(2): 151-169.

Edwards J, Hammersley G and Newell E (1990) Cost Accounting at Keswick, England, c.1598-1615: the German connection. Accounting Historians Journal 17(1): 61-80.

Fleischman R and Parker L (1991) British Entrepreneurs and Pre-Industrial Revolution Evidence of Cost Management. Accounting Review 66(2): 361-375.

Foucault M (1991) Governmentality. In: Burchell G, Gordon C and Miller P (eds) The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality. Birmingham: Harvester Wheatsheaf, pp. 87–104.

Garner S (1954) The evolution of Cost Accounting to 1925. Alabama: University of Alabama Press.

Guseva A (1990) Work with rare and valuable editions: Identification of copies of the Moscow Cyrillic books of the second half of XVI-XVIII c. Moscow. Гусева А.А. Работа с редкими и ценными изданиями: Идентификация экземпляров московских изданий кирилловского шрифта второй половины XVI-XVIII вв. Москва.

Gutiérrez-Hidalgo F, Larrinaga C and Nunez M (2005) Cost and management accounting in pre–industrial revolution Spain. (December 9, 2008). Accounting Historians Journal, Vol. 32, No. 1. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1313743.

Larrinaga C Nunez M Gutiérrez-Hidalgo F (2008) An Institutional Analysis of Cost Accounting Practices in the Spanish Eighteenth Century. Universidad Pablo de Olavide, Department of Business Administration, Working Papers. Available: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/5218714

Hammersley G (Ed.) (1988) Daniel Hechstetter the Younger: Memorabilia and Letters, 1600-1639. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner.

Ivanov V (2005) Accounting in Russia at XVI- XVII c. Historical-source-study of monastic accounts books. St Peterburg: Izdatelstvo «Dmitry Bulanin». Иванов В.И. Бухгалтерский учет в России в XVI- XVII вв. Историко-источниковедческое исследование монастырских приходно-расходных книг. СПб.: Изд-во «Дмитрий Буланин».

Johnson HT and Kaplan RS (1987) Relevance Lost: The Rise and Fall of Management Accounting. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.

Karelskaia S and Zuga E (2014) First institution of higher accounting education in Russia. In: Proceedings of the international conference on accounting, auditing, and taxation (ed J Alver), Estonia, Tallinn, 11-12 December 2014, pp. 269–276. Lancaster: Destech publications.

King P (2010) Mangement, finance and cost control in the Midlands charcoal iron industry. Accounting, Business & Financial History 20(3): 385-412.

Kiselev N (1960) Moscow typography in XVII c. In: Book: Research and materials: Vol.2. Moscow: Nauka, pp.123-186. Киселев Н.П. О московском книгопечатании XVII в. Книга: Исследования и материалы, Сб.2. Москва: Наука, с.123-186.

Klyuchevskiy V (1908) Course of Russian History. Vol.3. St.Petersburg: Typography G. Lissner and D. Sobko. Ключевский В.О. Курс русской истории. Т. 3. СПб: Типография Г. Лисснера и Д. Собко.

Kuter M and Sokolov V (2012) Russia. In: Previts GJ, Walton P and Wolnizer P (eds) A Global History of Accounting, Financial Reporting and Public Policy: Eurasia, the Middle East and Africa. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Emerald Group Publishing Limited.

Latour B (1987) Visualization and cognition: Thinking with eyes and hands. In: Kuklick H and Jones R (eds) Knowledge and Society: Studies in the Sociology of Culture Past and Present. Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp. 61–40.

Lemarchand Y (1994) Double entry versus charge and discharge accounting in eighteenth-century France. Accounting, Business & Financial History 4 (1): 119-145.

Littleton A (1927) The antecedents of double-­‐entry. The Accounting Review 2 (2): 140-­‐149.

Lukyanova Y (1996) Old printed books and the archive of the Moscow Printing House. In: Moscow Cyrillic books of the XVI-XVII centuries in collections RGADA: Catalog, Vol.1. Moscow: Archaeographic Center. Лукьянова Е.В. Старопечатные книги и архив Московского печатного двора. Московские кирилловские издания XVI-XVII вв. в собраниях РГАДА: Каталог. Москва: Археографический центр.

Luppov S (1983) Readers of publications of the Moscow printing house in the middle of the XVII century. Leningrad. Луппов С.П. Читатели изданий Московской типографии в середине XVII в. Ленинград.

Lvova D (2014) The sources of accounting theory of public sector economy. St Petersburg: S-P University. Львова Д.А. Истоки теории бухгалтерского учета общественного сектора экономики. Санкт-Петербург: Издательство Санкт-Петербургского университета.

Lvova I and Lvova D (2016) Reflections on the accounting profession in Russia in the late nineteenth - early twentieth century. 5th International Conference on Accounting, Auditing, and Taxation (ICAAT), Tallinn, Estonia, AEBMR-Advances in Economics Business and Management Research, Vol. 27 p.307-317.

Mattessich R (2008) Two Hundred Years of Accounting Research. An international survey of personalities, ideas and publications (from the beginning of the nineteenth century to the beginning of the twenty-first century). New York, Routledge

Mackevichius I (1974) Cost accounting. The historical aspect. Vilnius: University. Мацкевичюс И.С. Калькулирование себестоимости продукции. Исторический аспект. Вильнюс: ВГУ.

McKendrick N (1970) Josiah Wedgwood and cost accounting in the industrial revolution. Economic History Review 23(1): 45-67.

Medvedev M and Nazarov D (2007) History of accounting in Russia (1246–1996). Мoscow: Buhgaltersky uchet. Медведев М.Ю., Назаров Д.В. История русской бухгалтерии (1246-1996). Москва: Бухгалтерский учет.

Mepham M (1988) The eighteen-century origins of cost accounting. Abacus 24(1): 55-74.

Miller P (1990) On the interrelation between accounting and the state. Accounting, Organizations and Society 15(4): 315–338.

Miller P and Napier С (1993) Genealogies of Calculation. Accounting, Organizations and Society 18 (7/8): 631–647.

Motyka W (1990) The Impact of Western Europe on Accounting Development in Tsarist Russia Prior to 1800. Abacus 26(1): 36-62.

Napier C (2001) Accounting history and accounting progress. Accounting History NS 6(2): 7-31.

Nikitin M (2001) The birth of a modern public sector accounting system in France and Britain and the influence of Count Mollien. Accounting History 6(1): 75-101.

Nikolayevskiy P (1890) Moscow Printing House under Patriarch Nikon. Khristianskoye chteniye 1:114-141, 2:434-167. Николаевский П.Ф. Московский Печатный двор при патриархе Никоне. Христианское чтение.

Nuñez M. (2002) Organizational Change and Accounting: The Gunpowder Monopoly in New Spain, 1757-87. Accounting, Business & Financial History 12(2): 275-315.

Platonova N (2009) Peter the Great's government reforms and accounting practice in Russia. Accounting History 14(4): 437-464.

Pokrovskiy A (1913) Printed Moscow yard in the first half of the XVII century. Moscow: Tipografiya Voronova. Покровский А.А. Печатный Московский двор в первой половине XVII века. Москва: Типография Воронова.

Pozdeeva I (2017) Heirs of the Russian first printer. In: Book: Research and materials: Vol.3-4. Moscow: Nauka, pp.65-88. Поздеева И.В. Наследники русского первопечатника. Книга: Исследования и материалы, Сб.3-4. Москва: Наука, с.65-88.

Pozdeeva I, Pushkov V and Dadykin A (2001) Moscow Print Yard: Fact and Factor of Russian Culture, 1618-1652. Moscow: Izdatel'stvo ob"yedineniya "Mosgorarkhiv". Поздеева И.В., Пушков В.П., Дадыкин А.В. Московский печатный двор - факт и фактор русской культуры, 1618-1652 гг. Москва: Издательство объединения «Мосгорархив».

Pozdeeva I, Pushkov V and Dadykin A (2007) Moscow Print Yard: Fact and Factor of Russian Culture, 1652-1700. In two volumes. Moscow: Nauka. Поздеева И.В., Пушков В.П., Дадыкин А.В. Московский печатный двор - факт и фактор русской культуры, 1652-1700 гг. В двух томах. Москва: Наука.

Rogov А (1979) Typography. In: Essays on Russian Culture XVII c.: Part 2, pp. 155-169. Moscow. Рогов А.И. Книгопечатание. Очерки русской культуры XVII в., Москва, ч.2, с.155-169.

Prieto B and Larrinaga C (2001) Cost Accounting in Eighteenth-Century Spain: The Royal Textile Factory of Ezcaray. Accounting History 6(2): 59-90.

Sangster A and Rodrigues L (2013) The role of the state in the development of accounting in the Portuguese-Brazilian Empire, 1750-1822. Accounting History Rewiew 23(2): 161-184.

Sapunov B (1983) Antique literature in Russian libraries of the XVII century and Moscow Baroque. In: Russian libraries and their readers. Moscow, pp.60-70. Сапунов Б.В. Античная литература в русских библиотеках XVII в. и московское барокко. Русские библиотеки и их читатель. Москва.

Sargiacomo M (2006) Using accounting records to enhance an understanding of a seventeenth-century Italian feudal community: the case of the Commune of Penne (1664–90). Accounting History 11(4): 475–502.

Sazonova L (1978) Prolog as a literary form. In: 17th century literary collection Prolog. Moscow, pp.28-30. Сазонова Л.И. Проложное изложение как литературная форма. Литературный сборник 17 века Пролог. Москва, с.28-30.

Sazonova N (2008) On the origins of Russian Church schism in the 17th century: the correction of the liturgical books under Patriarch Nikon (1654-1666). Tomsk: Publishing House of Tomsk State Pedagogical University. Сазонова Н.И. У истоков раскола Русской Церкви в XVII веке: исправление богослужебных книг при Патриахе Никоне (1654-1666 гг.). Томск: Изд-во ТГПУ.

Sidorova M, Nazarov D and Vakhrushina M (2018) The Enlightenment as determinant of accounting change: The case of royal estate bookkeeping during the reign of Catherine II. Accounting History, December, 13, 2018, DOI:10.1177/1032373218814269.

Sokolov V, Karelskaia S and Zuga E (2018) Accounting for vodka in Russia. In: Quinn M and Oliveira J (eds) Accounting for Alcohol: An Accounting History of Brewing, Distilling and Viniculture. New York: Routledge, p. 122-138.

Sokolov Ya (1985) History of development of accounting. Moscow: Finance and Statistics. Соколов Я.В. История развития бухгалтерского учета. Москва: Финансы и статистика.

Solovyov A (1917) Moscow Print Yard. Moscow: Sinodal'naya tipografiya. Соловьев А.Н. Московский Печатный Двор. Москва: Синодальная типография.

Solovyev S (1879) History of Russia since Ancient Times, Vol. 10-13. St. Petersburg: Tovarishchestvo ‘Obshchestvennaya polza’. Соловьев С.М. История России с древнейших времен. Тома 10-13. СПб, Издание Товарищества «Общественная польза».

Spraakman G and Wilkie A (2000) The development of management accounting at the Hudson´s Bay Company, 1670-1820. Accounting History NS 5(1): 59-84.

Yamey B (1981) Some reflections on the writing of a general history of accounting. Accounting and Business Research 11(42):127-135.

Zambon S and Zan L (2007) Controlling Expenditure, or the Slow Emergence of Costing at the Venice Arsenal, 1586-1633. Accounting, Business & Financial History 17: 105-128.

Zernova A (1958) Cyrillic books, published in Moscow in the XVI-XVII centuries: Consolidated catalog. Moscow: Tipografiya Biblioteki imeni V. I. Lenina. Зернова А.С. Книги кирилловской печати, изданные в Москве в XVI-XVIIв.: Сводный каталог. Москва: Типография Библиотеки им. В.И. Ленина.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.26784/issn.1886-1881.v16i2.358

Enlaces refback

  • No hay ningún enlace refback.


Copyright (c) 2019 Marina I. Sidorova, Dmitry V. Nazarov

Licencia de Creative Commons
Este obra está bajo una licencia de Creative Commons Reconocimiento-NoComercial-CompartirIgual 4.0 Internacional.

Electronic ISSN:1886-1881

Indexes and Databases/ Índices y Bases de Datos: Google Scholar: H17Emerging Sources Citation Index 2015 Web of Science (Clarivate Analytics) , MIARDIALNETImpacto IDRREDIBIntegrated Classification of Scientific Journals CIRCLATINDEX (Catálogo 2.0)ULRICHSERIH PLUS, y Business Source Complete (EBSCOhost).

URL of the previous website (with also updated content): http://www.decomputis.org/

URL del anterior website (con contenido también actualizado): http://www.decomputis.org/

This is an Open Access Journal. All content is freely available in accordance with the BOAI definition of open access. This work is - if not stated otherwise - under a "Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License". The full license can be viewed at  http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/  


Asociación Española de Contabilidad y Administración de Empresas (AECA) 

C/Rafael Bergamín, 16-B ; 28043 - Madrid (España)

aeca.es   -   info@aeca.es